Healing, Verification And Resurrection

I saw some more Todd Bentley on God TV last night. (Please don’t yawn if this is boring you, but this is a big issue for me, given impending meetings in Chelmsford. In any case, my wife and children will be back from a half-term holiday tomorrow, and I shall have less chance to watch and blog then.)

Anyway – the point is this. He announced during the meeting (which would have been Wednesday night’s) that he is taking on staff to look into verification of the claims to healing that thousands have made in connection with the ‘Florida Outpouring’. He was clear that he would not claim that every healing was true, and I thought that was a step forward. He said they would pass on medically verified claims to healing to the news networks. It was Bene Diction in a comment on my first post two weeks ago who wrote this:

In April The Province (a BC newspaper) asked for documentation of healings…

“When The Province asked to speak to someone who had been healed
through Bentley in either B.C. or Florida, Fresh Fire was unable to
find someone at short notice, citing difficulties with outdated contact
information locally, and record-keeping problems in Florida.”

So let’s hope this is a move in the right direction, if that doesn’t sound too patronising. It would certainly be better than the past antics of scallywags like Benny Hinn, who was filmed for a British TV documentary on healing evangelists around eight years ago. It took the TV company three months of badgering before his ministry was willing to put them in touch with anyone. They ended up interviewing a family where it turned out that healing had not taken place, and that ‘Pastor Benny’ had told them they needed to give more. I think, if memory serves me right, they gave another $1000 and the healing still didn’t happen.

Bentley did get very excited last night about resurrections from the dead – and frankly, who wouldn’t, if they had happened? (I’m not saying they hadn’t, I’m just retaining my natural caution here.) In one case, someone had been dead eight minutes before coming back to life. I have no problem with such a story, except that I believe such stories also exist outside of claims to miraculous answers to prayer. I’m open to correction, especially from medics, if I’m wrong about that.

Another story came in by phone from Kenya. At first, it was mistakenly claimed to have medical verification from a doctor. It turned out that a doctor had prayed over the phone, and a hundred kilometres away, someone had been raised from the dead. That one awaits verification, I would have thought – much as I hope it is true.

Certainly, Bentley said a lot about resurrection last night. I felt that in his teaching, he let his excitement get the better of him. Emphasising that Jesus is the resurrection and the life, and that if we have Jesus we therefore have life, he got within a whisker of saying that dying without being raised back to life was an act of unfaith. Am I being unfair? Did I mishear or misunderstand? It was the impression I gained, though. And if I’m right, then the tone of the teaching was that everything was ‘kingdom now’, resurrection now, a little bit like the Corinthian Christians whom Paul had to correct for believing that the resurrection had already taken place.

To that I would reiterate what I learned from the likes of John Wimber in the mid-80s, that the kingdom of God is a mixture of the ‘now’ and the ‘not yet’. I hope and pray that we get as much of it in the ‘now’ as God wills, however much that is. But clearly a large part of it is delayed, not least the resurrection of the body, conquering the last enemy death. (This is in contrast to resurrection-resuscitations, like Lazarus and the son of the widow at Nain, who came back to life, only to die again later.)

In that respect, I found something my college principal said when I was training for the ministry. Talking about John Wesley‘s controversial doctrine of Christian perfection, he said that at heart, Wesley had ‘an optimism of grace’. Bentley has a huge optimism of grace, and it may be that people like him are sent to the church and the world to encourage us to be less pessimistic in our belief in God. Yet however optimistic we are about the grace of God, we still need a theology for when the blessings of God’s kingdom are mysteriously deferred.

Finally, I thought I’d end this with a link to something Ben Myers wrote on the Faith And Theology blog yesterday. Talking movingly about his elderly father’s struggles with ill health, he quoted Karl Barth on the subject of illness and healing. Barth is writing about the medical profession, but as I read his words, I was struck with just how much charismatics and Pentecostals with healing ministries would want to say something very similar. The quotes below are from Church Dogmatics III/4, s55:

“Sickness, like death itself, is unnatural and disorderly. It is an
element in the rebellion of chaos against God’s creation. It is an act
and declaration of the devil and demons. To be sure, it is no less
bound to God and dependent on Him than the creature which He created.
Indeed, it is impotent in a double way. For like sin and death, it is
neither good nor is it willed and created by God at all, but is real,
effective, powerful and menacing only in its nullity, as part of that
which God has negated, as part of His kingdom on the left hand.…

realm of death which afflicts man in the form of sickness … is opposed
to His good will as Creator and has existence and power only under His
mighty No. To capitulate before it, to allow it to take its course, can
never be obedience but only disobedience towards God. In harmony with
the will of God, what humans ought to will in face of this whole realm
on the left hand, and therefore in face of sickness, can only be final
resistance.… Those who take up this struggle obediently are already
healthy in the fact that they do so, and theirs is no empty desire when
they will to maintain or regain their health” (pp. 366-69).

“When one person is ill, the whole of society is really ill in all its
members. In the battle against sickness the final human word cannot be
isolation but only fellowship” (p. 363).

The full post is here.


  1. Bill,

    Thank you for your kind words. Coming from someone whose own writing I admire, I am honoured.

    As you may possibly have seen from the note I inserted before posting the text of tomorrow’s sermon last night, unfortunately I was unable to get to the local ‘impartation’ meeting yesterday evening. However, I shall stay in as close touch as I can with what is going on, and try to offer some pastoral theological reflection.

    It only struck me after writing this piece that I should have gone back and re-read part of Rob McAlpine’s book, especially on the ‘Kingdom Now’ and Latter Rain stuff. Most of my charismatic experience has been within the context of mainline denominations, and as you doubtless know, there hasn’t been in the UK quite such a divide between mainline and evangelical/Pentecostal churches. This, I think, has helped contribute towards less extreme charismatic theology for those within the movement but who also remained in the historic denominations. (There are the inevitable exceptions to that statement.)

    Every blessing, Bill.


  2. Dave,
    I live sixty feet from a Baptist Church (where I was once an Elder) that was blown apart by the excesses of the Toronto Blessing. The pastor still barks on the occasional Sunday – but there are fewer and fewer people to notice. Rumour has it that the church may not survive the year. It’s profoundly sad. Alan Roxburgh was once the pastor of that church (when I first became an elder.)


  3. Bill,

    Thanks for commenting again (and your separate email to me). To my astonishment, this post has been awarded the ‘Best of the Methoblogosphere’ in this week’s round-up of Methodist blogs.

    It is a tragedy when the ‘Toronto Blessing’ ends in the way you describe. The animal noises were always among the most contentious, and supported with some of the most ludicrous biblical exegesis (roaring on the grounds that ‘the Lion of Judah roars’, indeed). Without knowing the church to which you refer, the kindest this sounds like is a case of majoring on minors, but from what you hint at, it must have been much worse than that. And I say all that as someone whom God met in the ‘Blessing’, and for whom it was a healing experience after a torrid first three years in the ministry.

    I hope to post further on the ‘Florida Outpouring’, but can’t watch any coverage tonight as my wife has the TV for ‘Lost’ – it’s her holy hour!


  4. The claims of a child (3 year old) Jayed on the platform were not true.

    Charisma Magazine had to print an retraction (May 22nd)

    Bentley was seen by his audience talking to the ‘father’ Chuck sitting by his healed daughters bedside.

    Jayed died, Bentley reported she died in a Lakeland meeting May 28th by saying “a new age lady went into her room to pray for her.”

    There has been another case of a minister who went to Lakeland, claimed complete healing (this man was very loved by his congregation and had cancer) He died last week.


  5. Bene,

    Thanks for reporting these tragic stories. They are exactly what I feared might be true, in at least some cases. I’m guessing these reports are currently only available in print and not on the web, as I’ve unsuccessfully tried Googling for them, or searching Charisma magazine’s site.


  6. Thanks for this, which I wish I had found earlier. I’m glad Todd is working on the verification thing. I love the Barth quote.

    You should read the supposed retraction which Bene apparently refers to, which is in fact not a retraction at all, and which is available online here. See what I wrote here in response to a similar comment by Bene on my blog.


  7. I was healed in a Todd Bentley meeting a year ago March. I had cists on my ovaries that disappeared and this was confirmed with a subsequent ultra sound. Todd did not have a specific word of knowledge for me but rather a lady with ovarian cancer. My doctor was worried that the cists might be cancer and I asked God to heal me also. I did feel a warmth and the next week the ultra sound confirmed the cists were gone. My doctor was very excited for me.

    I did not respond to the article in the Province when they wanted proof because I did not want to participate in the media circus and also because they are not always accurate in what they report.
    I am still well a year later. Nor would Todd have been able to direct the media to me because he never showed any interest in hearing me when I approached him to tell him of the results.

    They are however, documenting claims being made in Lakeland and there will be some investigative journalism looking into the matter. They are aware that some people falsify claims just to get close to Todd or get the limelight while others are genuinely sincere.

    I am sure the subsequent documentary will make this all clear. I know the person doing this work and he has the highest integrity. He will not be interested in skewing anything or spinning stories to generate more hype. He is cautious and thorough in his approach.


  8. Aeriol,

    I was delighted to hear your story, with the clear verification of healing and your testimony regarding the person working on the documentary. While it surprises me to read that Todd Bentley wasn’t interested in your story, I hope the investigations into verification in Lakeland suggest a different tone. I am sure I am not the only person reading this to be thrilled to know that God healed you. I am sure my blogging friend Peter Kirk will add a hearty ‘Amen’!


  9. Indeed, Aeriol, Amen! I am thrilled to hear of your healing. I suspect Todd was not interested simply because you case is just one of thousands worldwide, many if not all genuine.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s